Perceived educational value and enjoyment of a rural clinical rotation for medical students

Introduction: It is well-recognised that medical students whose training exposure is largely limited to tertiary-level training hospitals may be inappropriately equipped to deal with the most relevant health issues affecting rural communities. This article evaluated the perceived educational value of a 2 week clinical rotation undertaken by senior undergraduate medical students at rural district hospitals and health care centers in the Western Cape Province, South Africa. Methods: Students completed a daily log diary to provide an overview of time spent on specific academic activities, ranking the educational and enjoyment value of each activity. At the end of the 2 week rotation students completed an open-ended questionnaire capturing the main positive and negative aspects of their experience, followed by focus group discussions with a randomly selected subgroup. In addition, a formal feedback seminar was arranged with the academic supervisors at each of the training sites to triangulate the information received and to document their perspective. Results: Thirty-seven students consented to study participation and 25 (68%) adequately completed the log diaries and questionnaires, rating the following activities as most educational: ‘assisting in theatre’, ‘teaching by doctor’, ‘seeing patients in clinic/health centre/OPD’ and ‘mobile clinic excursions’. The rural experience allowed practical application of their theoretical knowledge, which improved their levels of confidence and enjoyment. The most enjoyed activities were: ‘mobile clinic


Introduction
In 1978, the World Health Organisation (WHO) held an international conference at Alma Ata to raise global awareness and interest in primary health care.Optimizing primary health care was identified as the most important intervention to achieve the goal of 'Health for all by the year 2000' 1,2 .Since then there has been considerable attention to the redevelopment and refinement of concepts such as 'general practice' and 'family medicine' 1,[3][4][5] .Healthcare systems in many countries have been reformed, assigning a more prominent role to primary health care and the general medical practitioner [6][7][8][9][10][11][12] .Based on these and other significant developments 13 , family medicine is now recognized as a specialty discipline in South Africa, with family medicine practitioners being called 'family physicians' 14 .
In keeping with expectations regarding the role of family physicians, South Africa and many other countries have increased the amount of undergraduate medical teaching that takes place outside tertiary-level training hospitals 1,[15][16] .
During the 1970s, ambulatory settings were already suggested for training of medical students 17 , and the functions of a family medicine preceptorship was studied in the years 1976-1977 18 .Following these developments, a model using local health centres in undergraduate medical education was proposed 19 .Internationally, primary health care centres (PHCC, or 'clinics') and district level general hospitals, both urban and rural, subsequently became the settings of choice for training undergraduate medical students [20][21][22] .
In January 1998, a 2 week period ('rotation' or 'clerkship') of community-based training in the Division of Family Medicine and Primary Care (DFMPC) was introduced to the medical curriculum at the Faculty of Health Sciences (FHS), Stellenbosch University (SU) 15 , although community-based medical education had been offered in other disciplines, such as Obstetrics and Gynaecology, since the 1970s.Medical students rotated to urban PHCC within a 50 km radius of the faculty, and rated their experiences positively, in agreement with results reported in the international literature [23][24][25]  Numerous assessment tools to evaluate students' theoretical knowledge and clinical skills acquisition (competence) have been described 20,[26][27][28][29][30][31] .Log diaries were introduced as a data collection instrument to document accurately how students spend their time in various medical training environments; the value of this instrument has been substantiated in a number of studies [32][33][34][35] .
Due to the recent focus on community-based or rural clinical settings as preferred locations for clinical education, the goal of this study was to gain insight into students' experiences in such settings, both from academic and experiential points of view.Even with some evidence regarding the value of community-based rotations or clerkships in Africa 36 , the value of rural rotations has mainly been described in Canada, the USA and Australia [37][38][39][40][41][42] , with very limited evidence that indicates the unique value of undergraduate rural rotations in developing countries 43 .Specifically, the perceived educational value and enjoyment of such rural rotations have not been assessed together in a single study.The aim of this study, therefore, was to evaluate students' academic activities, together with the perceived educational value and enjoyment of a 2 week clinical rotation in a rural setting in South Africa, for medical students in their 4th or 5th year of study (Middle Clinical Rotations), using a log diary-based approach.Both quantitative and qualitative methods were used.

Setting
The study was conducted at Stellenbosch University's Students return to the faculty 2 weeks later (on the final Friday) and present their experiences to a faculty supervisor.

Recruitment
Between July and September 2007 (second semester), 37 medical students, in their 4th or 5th academic year (MBChB IV/V) were invited to take part in the study.Each

Instruments
A UK study used anonymous log diaries to describe how students spent their time in a primary care setting during a general practice rotation 33 .An adapted version of that log diary was used to accurately document the time students spent on educational and non-educational activities during the 2 week rural rotation of the present study (Appendix I, Table 1).Students reported all activities between 07.00 h and 19.00 h, using standard activity codes (Table 1) derived from those used in the UK study 33 , and adapted following discussion with students, supervisors and senior family physicians.A standard log diary provides information on how students spend their time but it does not capture the quality of their experience.Therefore we included a Likert scale to rate the educational and enjoyment value of each activity.Students were also requested to document whether they made themselves available to assist after hours and how they valued this exposure.Availability after hours for certain periods is compulsory and arranged on-site.
To improve the quantitative part of the assessment students were requested to respond to five opinion testing statements at the end of their rural rotation: two aimed to establish if local supervisors (preceptors) were both punctual and wellprepared.Another two statements aimed to evaluate the acquisition of relevant clinical skills; and a fifth attempted to ascertain if students found the rural rotation enjoyable/ purposeful (Table 2).
We included a formal questionnaire at the end of the log diary (for completion at the end of the rural rotation).
It included eight open-ended questions and a reflective summary of the experience (Table 3).Formal focus group discussions were conducted with a randomly selected subgroup of students, whether they adequately completed their log diaries or not.Discussions were recorded on a digital voice recorder which was used to prepare formal transcripts of the meetings.In addition, the study coordinator took written field notes during the discussions, identifying the main themes as they emerged.Themes identified were triangulated with the written responses received and included if they were supported by at least 50% of students. In

Positive responses
Negative responses Theme: part of the team / friendly staff Quotes: "friendly staff, especially the nurses, grateful patients" (Q5); "most of the staff were nice to us, we felt part of the team" (Q5); "the doctors and health workers were pleasant to work with" (Q8).

Theme: structure of rural rotation
Quotes: "structuring it better" (Q2); "outcomes should be relevant to the experience gained at the site" (Q2); "poor structuring of events/time-table" (Q6).

Theme: duration of rural rotation
Quotes: "the time spent there is too short" (Q2); "Time limit.Feel they are trying to cramp [sic] too much into only two weeks" (Q6).Theme: performing procedures Quotes: "mobile clinics and procedures" (Q1); "doing clinical procedures in the outpatients/emergency room…feeling like part of the team" (Q1); "I could refine my procedural skills and knowledge" (Q8).

Theme: working in the community
Quotes: "seeing how the community works" (Q1); "going into the community to do home visits" (Q1); "this exposed me to the hardships and challenges experienced by people in poor rural communities" (Q8); "Transport is a big problem" (Q3); "poor sanitation and housing infrastructure" (Q3).Theme: consultation skills Quote:"consultation skills, watching the GP" (Q1); "Working in casualty.You learn a lot there, procedures and consultation and pills" (Q1).

Overall responses
"Yes, more help is required in the rural setting, less hierarchy within the hospital setting" (Q7)."Yes, I love the variety of fields one works with in primary health care" (Q7)."It was highly educational and thought-provoking.I learnt a lot about primary health care, gained procedural skills and improved my theoretical knowledge too.I think it is important for students to go places like this because we get very limited exposure in the academic hospital settings; we don't realize that most of the patients we see come via primary healthcare facilities.It was also good to see what the common conditions are that present to primary hospitals because these are conditions that we as GPs are going to treat one day" (Q8).
The perceived educational value and enjoyment rating of each activity are shown (Table 1  In terms of their most valuable learning experiences (Table 3), students emphasized the value of performing practical skills and procedures themselves under expert guidance, as well as assisting in theatre (responses to Question 1).Without prompting the students contrasted this to the limited exposure they received at the academic hospital.Students experienced staff and patients to be most friendly and accommodating (responses to Question 5), which contributed to a positive rural experience and influenced their commitment to gain more knowledge; one student referred to 'the friendly face of learning'.Another feature of the focus group discussion was the perception that they were allowed to practice 'real medicine', as opposed to theoretical medicine.As expressed by one student: The experience was GREAT.It allowed me to actually get the feeling of being a real doctor.I was allowed to handle patients and make a diagnosis on my own (with adequate supervision), everyone (the nurses and doctor) treated me like a colleague.
Students also emphasized the positive influence of good role models in their reflective summaries and one student wrote: '…doctors were really excellent role models with lots of practical clinical experience/ handling common problems'.
Critical feedback was grouped under the following themes: 'structure of the rotation', 'duration of the rotation', 'amount of academic work', and 'problems experienced by doctors'.
Question 2 allowed students to suggest how the educational experience could be improved, and Question 6 requested students to name factors or experiences that reduced the educational value of the rural rotation (Table 3).Some responses to these two questions referred to the formal structure of the rural rotation, with student quotes such as 'outcomes should be relevant to the experience' and 'poor structuring of events/ time-table'.Student feedback was unanimous, requesting that the amount of written project work be reduced, increasing the time available to learn more of the required clinical skills.Most students indicated that a time period of 2 weeks was too short for them to benefit optimally from the rotation.In the words of one student: We were just finding our feet, and now we must pack up and leave again.I feel I should stay here for at least another two weeks, because there is so much to learn.

Discussion
We report the successful use of the log diary approach to documenting how students spend their time on rural clinical rotations.We adapted the instrument to also capture In terms of teaching and supervised activities, our results (3.7 hours per day) compare with the situation at University College London, where students receive supervised teaching for 3.5-4 hours/day 33 .In one US study, however, students reportedly spent 13 hours a day on teaching and learning activities, receiving supervised teaching for approximately 6.5 hours 48 .Due to changes in the medical education landscape and curricula worldwide 49 , the educational value of rural rotations requires more intense scrutiny to evaluate appropriate contextualized training in different rural settings.
The need for more structured rural rotations is reflected in the qualitative feedback from the students (Table 3  The present study findings are comparable to previous studies performed in Africa.A study in Ethiopia identified the need to develop students' group skills, prepare mentors to facilitate learning, optimize scheduling and improve study facilities 36 .Egyptian students displayed a preference for passively acquired information, although they indicated a willingness to increase their own involvement in learning 50 . In terms of a broader contribution of community-based settings to medical education, the potential for collaboration between community-based health programs and institutions of higher education have been described in Kenya (COBES network) 51 .They also introduced a theoretical framework to facilitate this type of learning collaboration in developing countries 51 .Collaborations among African institutions and universities from the UK and USA were also reported as successful [52][53] , but most of these reports utilized crosssectional retrospective surveys to assess students' learning experiences.The unique feature of the present study is the fact that we used both quantitative and qualitative modes of enquiry.This, together with the use of prospective data collection by students using the log diary approach, increased the scientific rigour of the methodology and allowed triangulation of data from different sources and demonstrated complementary findings.

Conclusion
This study evaluated the perceived educational experience of medical students during a rural clinical rotation by use of a log diary.Our results support the use of the log diary as both a quantitative and qualitative instrument to evaluate the educational experience of students, although it may benefit from some adjustments.The study demonstrates that students enjoy the experience and value the educational exposure of working in well-functioning rural health care centers with adequate local supervision and guidance.

Faculty
of Health Sciences, Cape Town, South Africa.As part of community-based medical education in practice, a pre-determined number of 4th and early 5th year medical students undergo a 2 week rural clinical rotation.This represents the first or second time in their undergraduate training that medical students leave the academic environment for medical training (some students experience a rotation away from the tertiary complex during their 3rd academic year, as part of the Early Clinical Rotation).During this Middle Clinical Rotation students complete written assignments and projects for three disciplines (combined into a single 2 week rotation): family medicine and primary care, rehabilitation and community medicine.The rotation starts with an introductory lecture on Monday morning, after which students travel to their assigned rural setting.On arrival (by 14.00 h the same day) students are introduced to hospital/ clinic staff and receive a brief orientation.Arrangements for travelling and accommodation are facilitated by the Ukwanda Centre for Rural Health.
of these students rotated to a district level hospital at one of the following sites: Caledon, Ceres, Citrusdal, Hermanus, Malmesbury, Swellendam or Worcester.Local academic supervisors at each site facilitated student learning, mainly through active participation and in-service learning.The principal investigator met with each of the student groups immediately after their introductory lecture, explained the objectives of the research project and invited participation.During these briefing sessions, students were assured that: (i) participation was entirely voluntary; (ii) no individuals would be identified either during analysis or in reporting; and (iii) participation in the study would in no way influence their formal assessment; students were free to withdraw from the study at any time.In addition, students were briefed about possible inclusion in focus group discussions after their rural rotation.Participants of the focus group discussions were randomly selected and invited by text message (SMS).Separate written informed consent was obtained for the log diary element of the study and for the focus group discussion.The study was approved by the Committee of Human Research, SU.

Table 3 :
Representative quotes from students to open ended questions recorded in the log diary and/or during focus group discussions Open ended questions: Q1 What was your most valuable learning experience?Q2 In your opinion, how can the educational experience at the rural site be improved?Q3 During the rotation, did you become aware of specific problems related to the experiences of poor people in rural areas / equitable health care?Elaborate.Q4 Have you gained new insight into problems experienced by medical personnel in rural areas?Q5 Name factors/experiences that made your rural rotation a good educational experience.Q6 Name factors/experiences that reduced the educational value of your rural rotation.Q7 In future, will you consider returning to rural settings once you are a qualified practitioner?Q8 Please provide a short reflective summary of your experience.
qualitative information regarding the perceived educational value of various activities.During feedback from students © NW Wilson, PAJ Bouhuijs, HH Conradie, H Reuter, BB Van Heerden, B Marais, 2008.A licence to publish this material has been given to ARHEN http://www.rrh.org.au 8 and triangulation with supervisors, a major shortcoming identified was the little emphasis placed on after-hours academic activities.Being available after hours to assist with emergency procedures, such as Caesarian sections, was regarded as valuable exposure that was poorly captured by the log diary.Overall, our results are in agreement with what has previously been reported in the literature, confirming that medical students derive great educational value from wellsupervised rural clinical rotations[44][45][46] .They also enjoyed the rotations.In contrast to Murray et al.'s findings 33 that showed a disassociation between perceived educational value and the enjoyment rating of various activities, our results demonstrated congruence between the most enjoyed activities and those associated with the highest educational value.In terms of educational value, the following activities were rated most educational: 'assisting in theatre', 'teaching by doctor', 'seeing patients in clinic/health centre/OPD' and 'mobile clinic excursions'.With regards to the enjoyment ratings, the following activities were rated most enjoyable: 'mobile clinic excursions', 'performing medical procedures' and 'teaching by doctor'.During workshops held with the rural academic supervisors and faculty staff members, the high educational value and enjoyment rating attached to 'mobile clinic excursions' came as a surprise, partly because the educators had not had exposure to this activity themselves (because the mobile clinics are exclusively nurse driven).Overall ratings were high for all the clinical activities, but time spent traveling and/ or waiting was viewed as 'wasted time'.This indicates the importance of excellent planning (eg time-tables and transport) to enhance students' experience.The positive outcomes of the workshops held with rural academic supervisors included the ability to provide direct feedback and to triangulate the students' experiences with those of their supervisors, and the assistance provided to interpret responses in context.Feedback provided by the study guided subsequent improvements to the content and defined the outcomes of the Middle Clinical Rotation.Written responses were often very cryptic.Therefore, focus group discussions added immense value to the interpretation, because many students were able to express themselves best verbally.It also allowed capture of responses from students who failed to complete their log diaries.One student indicated that s/he missed life in the city and will never return to a rural setting.This student declined to document in the log diary, despite assurances of anonymity, demonstrating the importance of triangulation.It also indicates that the analyzed responses may be biased towards recording a positive experience.Similar to our observations, reports in the literature indicate that positive or negative role models are an influence on the ultimate career choices of students 47 .
Students indicated that the additional academic load of written reports and projects prevented them from maximizing the rural experience.This specific Middle Clinical Rotation consists of elements from three separate disciplines: (i) family medicine and primary care;(ii) rehabilitation; and (iii) community medicine.Students were unanimous in requesting that the amount of written project work be reduced to increase the time available to acquire clinical skills.The vast majority of students also indicated that a time period of 2 weeks is too short to derive greatest benefit from the rotation.

Table 1 : Time spent by medical students on various activity codes (07.00 h to 19.00 h) during a two-week rural clinical rotation and the perceived educational value plus enjoyment rating
summary, the diary component (Appendix I) and opinion testing statements included in the log diary were designed as instruments collecting quantitative data; however, the open Analysis Quantitative data from the log diaries were entered into a Microsoft Excel spreadsheet before transfer to GraphPad Prism TM v 4.00 (GraphPad Software, Inc) for analysis.The proportion of time spent on different activities was calculated using the sum of the half-hour segments marked in the diaries.Variability of results is expressed as standard deviations.Likert scale ratings were analyzed as continuous variables.The qualitative feedback was summarized according to the main themes identified by the principal researcher.case the 30 min were divided equally between the different activities reported.On average, students spent 6.4 hours/ day on teaching and learning activities and 3.7 hours being directly supervised.©NW Wilson, PAJ Bouhuijs, HH Conradie, H Reuter, BB Van Heerden, B Marais, 2008.A licence to publish this material has been given to ARHEN http://www.rrh.org.au 5 NGOs, Non-government organizations; OPD, outpatients department.*Cumulativenumber of hours spent per activity.†Educationalvalue expressed as average Likert scale value ± standard deviation.‡Enjoymentrating expressed as average Likert scale value ± standard deviation.§" Other" included all unspecified activities such as general meetings with staff prior to the start of a work shift.

Table 3
includes representative quotes in response to the open-ended questions, provided at the end of the rural rotation (written feedback) and during the focus group discussions.According to the student feedback received, the most valuable learning experiences were classified under the following five themes: 'feeling part of the team/ friendly staff', 'mobile clinics', 'performing procedures', 'working in the community' and 'consultation skills'.